Don’t Draft Women—Don’t Draft Anyone


In 2016, Senator John McCain (R-AZ) sponsored legislation that would compel women to register for the draft. Fortunately, the bill did not become law, though the Senate approved it, 85-13.1 But the issue is not dead.2 In June of this year, Congress considered a similar measure.3 Representative Jackie Speier (D-CA), who supports the change, said, “It’s time to stop delaying the inevitable.” Her most recent amendment calling for such compulsion failed a House Armed Services Committee vote by a razor thin 33–28 margin this year.4

McCain says that compulsory draft registration for women “is the logical conclusion of the decision to open combat positions to women.”5 But it isn’t logical at all. Permitting female volunteers to serve in combat roles does not logically entail that unwilling women should be forced to serve in the military. Think about it. Does availing the corporate ladder to women compel them to climb it? Of course not.

Missing the larger issue, many opponents of this legislation point out that men and women are often not equal in physical strength. For instance, during his 2016 presidential campaign, Senator Ted Cruz (R-FL) said, “I’m the father of two little girls . . .  They are capable of doing anything in their hearts’ desire, but the idea that their government would forcibly put them in the foxhole with a 220-pound psychopath trying to kill them, doesn’t make any sense at all.”6 Cruz has a point there. But does it even make sense to force a boy into a foxhole with such a psychopath?

Speier, for her part, gets it half right when she says, “If it does come to a draft, men and women should be treated equally.” Men and women do have an equal, inviolable right to their life, liberty, and pursuit of happiness. Government compulsion to register for the draft or to serve in the military violates those rights. The government should not forcibly put anyone in a foxhole, a tank, or anywhere else. Justice is not served by making men and women equal victims of injustice.

A few members of Congress recognize this. Senator Rand Paul (R-KY) introduced an amendment to the 2016 bill that would have eliminated draft registration altogether.7 And Representative Peter DeFazio (D-OR) laudably argued, “It doesn’t matter if you’re a man, a woman or a houseplant—we need to abolish the Selective Service.”8

Absolutely. The Declaration of Independence enshrines every citizen’s rights. Our government should strive to protect equal rights for men and women, not engage in equal trampling of those rights. Instead of broadening compulsory draft registration or military service to include women, our government ought to abolish this abomination.

Endnotes

1. Elaine Donnelly, “McCain’s Mandate for Co-ed Conscription” Washington Times, June 7, 2016, https://www.washingtontimes.com/news/2016/jun/7/john-mccains-mandate-for-drafting-women/ (Accesed November 10, 2017).

2. Jennifer Steinhauer, “Senate Votes to Require Women to Register for the Draft,” New York Times, June 14 2016, https://www.nytimes.com/2016/06/15/us/politics/congress-women-military-draft.html on 10/17/2017 (Accessed October 17, 2017).

3. Richard Sisk, “Congress Shelves Plans to Have Women Register for Draft,” Military.com, June 29, 2017 http://www.military.com/daily-news/2017/06/29/congress-shelves-plans-have-women-register-draft.html.

4. Rowan Scarborough, “Pentagon advocates requiring women to sign up for military draft,” Washington Times, Oct 24, 2017, https://www.washingtontimes.com/news/2017/oct/24/pentagon-advocates-requiring-women-to-sign-up-for-/ (Accessed November 10, 1027).

5. Travis J. Tritten, “Senate’s Armed Services Committee chairman backs women in the draft” Stars and Stripes, Feb 10, 2016 https://www.stripes.com/news/us/senate-s-armed-services-committee-chairman-backs-women-in-the-draft-1.393386, (accessed Nov 27, 2017).

6. Theodore Schleifer, “Ted Cruz: Making U.S. women eligible to be drafted is ‘nuts’,” CNN, February 8, 2016, http://www.cnn.com/2016/02/07/politics/ted-cruz-drafting-women-nuts/index.html (Accessed October 17, 2017).

7. Jacqueline Klimas, “Rand Paul introduces amendment to get rid of draft,”  Washington Examiner, May 24, 2016, http://www.washingtonexaminer.com/rand-paul-introduces-amendment-to-get-rid-of-draft/article/2592170, (Accessed October 17, 2017).

8. Jacqueline Klimas, “Rand Paul introduces amendment to get rid of draft,”  Washington Examiner, May 24, 2016, http://www.washingtonexaminer.com/rand-paul-introduces-amendment-to-get-rid-of-draft/article/2592170, (Accessed October 17, 2017).


Comments submitted to TOS are moderated and checked periodically. Anonymous posts are not permitted; commenters must use their real names. To be considered for posting, a comment must be civil, substantive, on topic, and no longer than 400 words. Ad hominem attacks, arguments from intimidation, misrepresentations, off-topic comments, and comments that ignore relevant points made in the article will be deleted. Thank you for helping us to keep the discussion intellectually profitable.